What will cost more in the education dispute in B.C.?

We need to talk. And no, I’m not being sarcastic. We really do need to talk, and in a way that speaks each other’s language

We need to talk. And no, I’m not being sarcastic. We really do need to talk, and in a way that speaks each other’s language, and in a way that we can each hear the validity in the other’s concerns.

Case in point: I and many of my fellow teachers have written countless public appeals for the government to do the right thing and to fund public education properly, an issue by the way which goes far beyond the proposals currently on the bargaining table. Ask a trustee.

The problem is that these letters and blogs almost always appeal to emotional sensibility, altruism and a sense of moral duty. All fine things and not surprising given that teachers are members by choice of a caring nurturing profession.

I think that instead we need to talk about economics.

The basic premise behind the government’s public position in resisting mediation boils down to “protection of the taxpayer.” In other words, what we are watching, in inimitable B.C. world wrestling-style political hyperbole, is really a policy debate over taxation.

It seems to me there are two potential positions for B.C. Liberal supporters: a) that public education should not be supported by tax dollars at all, in principle, or b) that a quality public education should be supported by tax dollars but mitigated by sound financial restraint.

Of the 30 per cent or so of the B.C. population that openly supports the government position, according to multiple polls, I am going to assume the majority of you fall into the latter. This is not idle speculation, either, as other polls have shown that a majority of B.C. taxpayers (regardless of political affiliation) support higher taxation, provided that the revenues flow to specific public benefits, such as schools, hospitals, infrastructure, etc.

I would argue that b) is a completely defensible position. My only issue with it is that I don’t believe the leaders you are supporting fall into the same category as you.

I will admit that I have no concrete proof that Christy Clark and Peter Fassbender fall into category a) above, but I ask you the following questions in the hopes that you will call for a more complete and transparent analysis of the economics of the situation.

• What will cost more? Investing in quality public education now, or paying later for all of the economic fall-out that research shows is correlated to poorer access to quality education.

• What will cost more? Settling 10 years of a retroactive grievance now for an unconstitutional injury, the fact of which is not up for debate, even in the upcoming court case, or kicking the problem down the road until such point that you are liable for the full damages.

• What will cost more? Paying the difference between the two positions as they stand, or shelling out $40 each and every day to a large portion of the 500,000 public school aged children in B.C.

As I say, I think we need to start to speak each other’s language and debate the issues for what they are.  I truly believe that the government’s economic argument is much weaker than it appears, but none of us can assess that properly if we are only offered spin instead of analysis.

Like bargaining, the success of a wider public debate like the one I am proposing will depend upon open, frank and honest commitment to facts and to the process.  That’s a long-term aspiration, though.

Mark Skanks, Local President,

Saanich Teachers’ Association

 

Just Posted

More buoys allowed for Brentwood Bay

Proposed number rises from 40 to 60

Victoria airport reaches nearly two million passengers in 2017

This year expected to see additional growth

Peninsula speed skating duo aiming for the national stage

Pair opted to train in long track skating this season for the first time

Tent city resident just wants a home

Roving tent city has made its way to Central Saanich

Island Health, service providers meeting to talk about used needles in Victoria

Recent public needle-prick incidents prompt call to reduce number of needles found

Sidney’s Salish Sea aquarium to close for maintenance

First extended closure for the Shaw Centre for the Salish Sea since it opened in 2009

Butchart Gardens is hiring now and paying more

Wages start at $15, job fair Feb. 20

Cash still needed for Stelly’s Cross Path

MLA Olsen wants more specifics first

Injured parachutist wants stolen backpack back

Bag contained important video files of 2017 parachuting incident

Body discovered in burnt out car near Trail

Police report a body was found in the burnt out trunk of a 1999 Honda Civic

VIDEO: B.C. Lions sign defensive back T.J. Lee to contract for upcoming season

The four-year veteran had a team-high four interceptions and 49 tackles last season with B.C.

How an immigrant to Canada helped Donald Trump prove his mental health

Test that cleared Trump was developed by doctor associated with McGill and Sherbrooke universities

Premier touches on multiple topics ahead of Asia trade trip

Housing and childcare are expected to be the focus of the BC NDP’s first budget in February.

Wanted by Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers for the week of Jan. 16

Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers is seeking the public’s help in locating the… Continue reading

Most Read