PETER DOLEZAL: Beware the performance claims

We have all seen mutual fund advertisements. Many claim great performance compared to market Indexes.

We have all seen mutual fund advertisements. Many claim great performance compared to market Indexes. Some are indeed fair claims. Others are not.

It is a fact that among roughly 3,500 Canadian mutual funds, some 20 per cent will beat the market in any given year — the other 80 per cent will not. The odds of an investor holding a winner in any given year is about one in five — slot machines in Vegas provide much better odds.

It is understandable the industry will choose to advertise the winners, as opposed to the laggards. Unfortunately, one year’s winning fund is often another year’s underperformer. Although selective advertising by the industry is to be expected, there are times when its ads are grossly misleading.

A dramatic example was highlighted by Andrew Hallam of the Strategy Lab, in his April 30, 2014 Globe & Mail article. He took a major, and popular, mutual fund provider, IA Clarington Investments Inc., to task for their advertised claims.

Clarington had boasted that three of their funds had delivered market-beating performances compared to Canadian Indexes. Unfortunately, none of the three funds held significant quantities of Canadian stocks — thus totally invalidating the comparison. The Clarington ad also claimed index-beating performance over the long term, however none of the advertised funds had existed for more than three years.

Hallam not only exposed Clarington’s disingenuous advertising, but went on to demonstrate the inferior performance of other Clarington funds which did, in fact, compare to Canadian, U.S. and international indexes. In virtually every fund he analyzed, Hallam demonstrated the Clarington fund had lagged the performance of the relevant index. He further demonstrated that had an investor held those Clarington funds for the previous decade, his holdings would have underperformed those of investors who had invested simply in the indexes — by a total 13.64 per cent.

This proven underperformance by mutual funds is to be expected. No matter how smart the mutual fund manager, it is extremely difficult to consistently beat an index by enough to counter the effect of the mutual fund’s fee premium, which annually, can total two per cent more than the fees charged by an Exchange Trade Fund (ETF) or an Index Fund.

Yes, buyers should always beware all advertised claims no matter what the product. Unfortunately, there are many who do not. With mutual funds, many take the ads at face value, continuing to accept the advice of advisors who promote and sell such funds, without acknowledging or offering much lower-cost alternatives.

Much more strict regulation of the mutual fund industry is long overdue in Canada.


A retired corporate executive, enjoying post-retirement as an independent Financial Consultant (, Peter Dolezal is the author of three books, including his recent Second Edition of The Smart Canadian Wealth-Builder.

Contact Panorama Rec Centre to register for Peter’s Elder College Fall session – Financial & Investment Planning for Retirees & Near-Retirees

(Thursdays, September 18 to October 16).


Just Posted

More Peninsula councillors declare their 2018 intentions

Carl Jensen and Chris Graham, both of Central Saanich, have said they will run again.

Woodwynn Farms to be shut down and sold

The rehabilitation program at Woodwynn Farms is being shut down. According to… Continue reading

Whisky society commits to charity donation in wake of whisky raids

Refund of Victoria Whiskey Festival tickets won’t impact charity beneficiaries

Peninsula scientist lauded for Arctic research

Scientist Eddy Carmack, an oceanographer and Central Saanich resident, is in Norway… Continue reading

Victoria housing provider launches crisis prevention program to combat homelessness

Pacifica Housing aims to address challenges before tenants risk evictions

Sidney’s Salish Sea aquarium to close for maintenance

First extended closure for the Shaw Centre for the Salish Sea since it opened in 2009

Butchart Gardens is hiring now and paying more

Wages start at $15, job fair Feb. 20

WHL winning streak ends at four in Kelowna for Victoria

Royals lose 8-4 as Rockets explode offensively

Cash still needed for Stelly’s Cross Path

MLA Olsen wants more specifics first

Wind warning back in effect around Vancouver Island

80 km/h winds expected Saturday, Jan. 20, on east coast of Island, 100 km/h on west coast

VIDEO: Thousands join women’s march events across B.C.

Today marks one year since the first Women’s March on Washington

UPDATE: BC Transit’s handyDart service strike delayed

LRB application by contractor means new strike notice must be issued by union

Two Canadians, two Americans abducted in Nigeria are freed

Kidnapping for ransom is common in Nigeria, especially on the Kaduna to Abuja highway

Are you ready for some wrestling? WWE’s ‘Raw’ marks 25 years

WWE flagship show is set to mark its 25th anniversary on Monday

Most Read