LETTERS: Celebration came too early

It’s easy to see how easily this deal could end up back in court, bringing another payday for lawyers.

An even slightly more careful reading of the B.C. Supreme Court ruling on Sidney’s proposed Community Safety Building, (PNR, April 15), reveals that Town Hall’s victory celebration was, at best, premature.

While Madam Justice D. Jane Dardi will, indeed, allow the North Saanich Memorial Park Society to negotiate a long-term land lease, the judge was specifically asked not to rule on the question of whether leasing the land to Sidney for the proposed community safety building would be an allowable use.

According to the ruling, the terms of the Trust require “use by the Residents . . . for community cultural, athletic and recreational purposes.” According to the Attorney General — who, in BC, supervises trusts — a public safety building doesn’t qualify.

And the Attorney General is not alone in her opinion. Though specifically asked not to “adjudicate upon … the proposed lease with the Town of Sidney,” it seems that Justice Dardi couldn’t entirely resist:

“I wish to underscore that I have not approved the proposed lease  … I must state that I share the Attorney General’s concern as to whether the tenant’s intended use … conforms to the charitable purposes of the Trust.”

So, why is Town Hall celebrating?

Why is their attendant publicity so buoyant and robust?

It’s easy to see how easily this deal could end up back in court, bringing another payday for lawyers.

In its relentless rush toward development, Town Hall has shown itself willing and able to run over the sentiments of the town.

The Supreme Court may well prove to be more difficult.

Don Enright, North Saanich

Just Posted

READERS’ CHOICE: Saluting the stars of the Saanich Peninsula

Welcome to the Peninsula News Review’s 13th annual Readers’ Choice Awards, our… Continue reading

Saanich Peninsula athletes earn their place at B.C. Games

The Saanich Peninsula will be well-represented next week as the 40th annual… Continue reading

A sled dog with an amazing past shows a young pug the ropes

A local school bus driver and passionate dog lover has written his… Continue reading

Victoria airport workers rally on Tuesday

Food service workers call for improved working conditions

Death-penalty decision delayed for alleged cold-case killer

William Talbott is charged here in the 1987 slaying of a young Victoria-area couple

BC Games: Opening Ceremony from Laketown Ranch

Hundreds of athletes and thousands of volunteers, coaches, parents and officials

B.C. city wants pot punted from farmland

Concerned about conversion from growing food to making marijuana

World’s translators push back on forcing Trump interpreter to testify

Democrats had asked translator to testify about Trump’s lengthy conversation with Putin in Helsinki

No decision on B.C. school stabbing suspect’s mental fitness for trial

The BC Review Board could not determine whether Gabriel Klein, 21, is fit to stand trial

FRESH IDEA: Victoria tech firm beneficiary of streamlined government system

Software developer FreshWorks awarded $1.5-million contract using new bid program

Canadian government threatens to retaliate if Trump imposes auto tariffs

U.S president had suggested that auto imports pose a national security risk to the U.S.

Wildfire evacuation order forces bride to search for new wedding venue

Fitzpatrick Family Vineyards is under an order due to the Mount Eneas wildfire south of Peachland

Recent online kitten abuse video raises serious social media questions

UBC and UFV profs weigh in on the subject of online sharing, shaming, and our digital landscape

UPDATED: ICBC fights back against claims that it’s ‘ripping off’ B.C. RV drivers

Canadian Taxpayers Federation is urging the provincial government to open up ICBC to competition

Most Read